Practicing Family Law With Heart For More Than 25 Years

Downsides of letting children decide which parent to live with

On Behalf of | Feb 19, 2024 | Child Custody

In Texas, the family court system aims to prioritize the best interests of the child when determining custody arrangements during divorce or separation. However, some parents wonder if they should let their children decide which parent to live with.

While considering children’s preferences is important, there are significant downsides to letting them decide.

Conflict and stress

In Austin, children younger than 18 years old make up 18.7% of the population. Many of these children have parents who do not live together.

Choosing between parents can create conflict and stress for children. It places them in a position where they may feel they are choosing sides. They may believe that the parent they do not choose will be angry or hurt. This can lead to feelings of guilt, anxiety or resentment toward one or both parents. Also, children might truly not be able to choose a parent, and no amount of urging can make them do so.

Potential for manipulation

Children, especially younger ones, may be susceptible to manipulation or influence from one parent. This can lead to biased decisions based on factors unrelated to the child’s well-being, such as promises of leniency or material possessions.

Lack of maturity

Children may not possess the emotional maturity or understanding of the long-term consequences involved in custody decisions. Short-term desires or emotions may influence their preferences, rather than what is truly best for their overall development and stability.

Limited perspective

Children may not fully comprehend the complexities of their parents’ circumstances or the practicalities of maintaining stable living arrangements. Their limited perspective can lead to decisions that do not consider important factors such as financial stability, proximity to schools or support networks.

Potential for regret

As children grow older, they may come to regret the decisions they made. What seemed like a good choice at the time may not align with their evolving needs and relationships as they mature. This can lead to feelings of dissatisfaction or resentment toward their parents for putting them in this position.

Undermining parental authority

Allowing children to unilaterally decide their living arrangements can undermine parental authority and contribute to a breakdown in the parent-child relationship. It may send the message that parents’ input and authority are insignificant, potentially leading to further behavioral issues or challenges in the parent-child dynamic.

Parents and the court system should carefully weigh all relevant factors to ensure that custody arrangements prioritize the child’s best interests and long-term well-being.